• Home
  • Authors
  • News
  • Events
  • Subscribe Facebook
  • Shana Galen is thrilled to announce When You Give a Duke a Diamond is a finalist in … MORE»

  • Cindy Kirk is happy to announce that The Doctor’s Not-So-Little Secret is a finalist in the short contemporary category … MORE»

  • People Magazine reviewed Kristan’s SOMEBODY TO LOVE, calling it “filled with genuine emotion” and “thoroughly entertaining.” Kristan is thrilled, … MORE»

See More News »

  • Kristan will be signing THE BEST MAN in Corning, NY, 4:30-7, Radisson Hotel at the Corning Glass Fest.

See More Events »

Deep dark secrets … and cheescake

My sister makes the best cheesecake I’ve ever had. She’s a great cook. No lie. She makes the best a lot of things I’ve ever had. In fact, I’ve made her promise that if I’m ever on death row, she’ll come cook my last meal.

Tonight I tried to recreate one of the recipes she often makes. She claims she got the recipe from Ina Garten, but my sister is a tweaker (no, that’s not a drug thing. At least not when I use it). So even though I went online and found the Ina Garten recipe, my weekday Bolognese tasted nothing like my sister’s. It was the cheesecake all over again.

This past summer, she and I had the chance to go to New York City together. We’d never traveled alone together and it was so much fun. One of the highlights was having brunch at Sarabeth’s right by Central Park. It lived up to all the great reviews. We had two big disappointments. The first was pizza (I’d sure we picked the wrong place). The second was the cheesecake. I looked around on line and found the best reviewed bakery in Little Italy.

Nevertheless, when we were sitting down with our three flavors of cheesecake, all I could say was, “It’s okay.”

“Yeah,” she said.

“Yours is better.”

She dropped her fork and looked at me, pale and aghast. “I think so, too!”

That was the last time I ate cheesecake that she hadn’t baked. I mean, what’s the point? But here’s the thing about my sister: no matter how her accomplishments, she plays them down.

“So where did you get your cheesecake recipe?” I asked once.

“Oh, it’s just the one on the cream cheese.”

“Really? ‘Cause I’ve made that and yours is better.”

“No, it’s the same,” she said, all innocence.

“The Philadelphia cream cheese?” I ask, disbelieving now.

“Sure. But I add a quarter cup of sugar. Oh, and I don’t use the crust. I use the crust recipe from the ghramcracker box. Except I add a half cup of sugar to that too. And I bake it fifteen minutes longer.”

“In other words, you use your own recipe that’s nothing like anything, anywhere?”

But that’s my sister for you. Her recipes are like closely guarded secrets. I know she loves me, I’m just not sure she loves me enough to share her recipes with me. However, she does love me enough to make me cheesecake, so I forgive her. With me, cheesecake buys you a lot.

So do you have any great recipes you don’t want to share with anyone?

I’ll give away a copy of my new books, All the Ever Wanted to one of the people who confesses  what recipes they keep close to their chests.

38 Comments
Leave a Comment
Share:
Filed in: Jaunty Post

Comments

  1. Katherine Garbera Said:

    Emily–my mom makes a really good cheesecake too, but then its an old family recipe that came down my maternal family line. One of the things I’ve noticed about my mom and my grandma’s recipes is that a lot of times they are simply ingredients with no instructions on what to do with them. If I don’t share a recipe its probably because I always do something a little different.

    Now you’ve got me craving cheesecake. I think I know what I’m doing today after I finish writing!

    - Reply
    • Emily McKay Said:

      Kathy, my grandmother was a pinch here, pinch there kind of cook. She was great, but it makes it hard to recreate her recipes. Even when I call her and ask for instructions, she can’t really help. But those kind of cooks are the best, right?

      - Reply
  2. kris Said:

    ha, that’s funny. I’m defininitely not much of a cook and rarely do it (we’d starve if my husband didn’t cook!) I have a couple of things that I do fairly well, the majority of which are hand-me-downs from my grandmother and they don’t have recipes. Plus, I’ve manipulated them a bit to suit my own tastes.

    - Reply
    • Emily McKay Said:

      Kris, I think the best recipes are the ones you tweak. But it does make it hard to share, doesn’t it?

      - Reply
  3. Sandi in OH Said:

    After 44 years of marriage, I don’t like to cook anymore. My recipes are simple because I don’t do complex. My attention span for reading is very good for cooking it is very short. I eat because it is necessary. When my son and his family moved to NC I shared my Pink Stuff recipe with my middle grandchild. My husband shared his deviled egg recipe with oldest grandchild. Both are boys.

    - Reply
    • Emily McKay Said:

      Okay, Sandi, I have to know, what is Pink Stuff????

      - Reply
  4. Mozette Said:

    My brother went through the horrors of being an apprentice chef – well okay, the first 2 years of the 4 year apprenticeship… it was pure and absolute hell! The hours were terrible, we never got to see him and when we did, all he talked about was the crap hours, the crap pay and how everyone he worked with were stoned or drunk; except the head chef who was teaching him… not a good look, eh?

    Well, he’s the best cook around in our family and he’s taught me that the best thing about being a good cook/chef is to be flexible and that your food tastes great. So, whenever I’ve got guests coming over, I make sure I cook something I know will work and they will walk away saying, “Bloody hell, I didn’t know she could make that in that little stove!” and I’ve amazed a few people in my time.

    My most famous dish presently is my Turkish Carrot Dip… I got it off Food Safari on SBS and the problem with how I learned about the recipe was that I could only hear what was going on as the reception on my television was so horribly bad, it was almost snow. So, I wrote down the ingredients and the method and tried it out – and it worked! And the best thing about this puppy is that it has only 4 ingredients and you can find them in your local health store. :)

    2 large carrots grated (use a food processor; it’s better, faster and there’s less blood than a hand-held grater)
    1 clove of garlic – raw, crush and smooshed within an inch of its life.
    1kg tub of Natural Plain Yoghurt (Greek Plain Yoghurt is even better as it’s richer)
    1 pinch of salt.

    Put the grated carrots into a pan with 1 tablespoon of olive oil and on a low heat. Watch them and let the pan heat up while they’re in there. Don’t hurry this part… and don’t let them burn. Allow the carrot to turn more orange (you’ll know what I mean when you see it) and go soft; taste it to make sure it’s soft, and then turn off the heat and let it cool down.
    Prepare the yoghurt in the bowl you’re going to use. Put the whole tub of yoghurt in the bowl, along with the garlic and the pinch of salt and mix well… then put it back into the fridge – covered – until the carrot cools. If the carrot’s ready by this time, little by little spoon it into the yoghurt mixture and mix it in well until it’s all in there. Then decorate with olives (optional) and sprinkle paprika over the top. Make this the day before and keep it in the fridge… YUMMO!

    This dip is great for kids who love anything creamy, just don’t tell them it’s healthy. And it doubles up as a condiment too… so dollop it on your salad at the bbq or Thanksgiving too. :D :cool:

    - Reply
    • Emily McKay Said:

      Mozzet, I’m totally going to try this! It sounds great!
      And, yes, I think being a chef is one of those jobs that seems glamorous and really, really isn’t.

      - Reply
  5. Connie Fischer Said:

    I love to cook and have some great recipes that my family loves. I would share them in a flash. I just don’t understand why someone wouldn’t. Food and love are supposed to be shared. The same goes for recipes!

    - Reply
    • Emily McKay Said:

      Connie, you’re so right! Food and love!
      And maybe my sister would share, but when I make her stuff, it never tastes as good. But maybe that’s just because things are always better when someone you love made them for you.

      - Reply
  6. Melody May Said:

    I’m not a big fan for cooking, but I love to bake. I don’t mind sharing my recipes, but I sometimes tweak a recipe to see if it works better. For instance, I like to add a about a half of cup of cake flour to my scones. Which gives it a fluffier texture than just using all purpose flour. When it comes to cookies I like to use more flour.

    - Reply
    • Emily McKay Said:

      Meloday, I totally agree about adding cake flour to all purpose for biscuits and scones, etc. I either do that or I buy southern flour if I can find it, because it has lower gluten, like the mixture does.

      - Reply
  7. CateS Said:

    Ok, I just stole that carrot receipe and intent to try it out for my next football game… I’ll share anything I know how to cook…

    - Reply
  8. eap Said:

    My grandma had recip for choclate cake she would not share.

    - Reply
    • Emily McKay Said:

      eap, my grandmother made the *best* chocolate cake. Again, mine never tasted like hers. She used an ingredient called Burnt Sugar Flavoring that I have never found here in Texas. As for her icing recipe, that I never managed at all.

      - Reply
  9. Shana Said:

    I have no recipes, Emily. And when I do have too cook and follow a recipe, I always follow it exactly. Unless I don’t understand it, and that happens way more than I’d like to admit.

    - Reply
    • Emily McKay Said:

      Shana, I’m a pretty good cook, but the real secret is that I’m a good recipe follower. I have no instinct for it. If it’s a good recipe, it’ll be good. The things I just “make up” are never great.

      - Reply
  10. erinf1 Said:

    I don’t cook (and have politely been asked not to by friends and family) but my paternal grandmother was notorious for not sharing recipes. Or if she did, she’d deliberately leave something out. She wanted hers to be the best and she did take several family favorites to the grave.

    - Reply
    • Emily McKay Said:

      erin, some people are just like that. Either they like that level of control or something. Or maybe they just need the praise.

      - Reply
  11. catslady Said:

    I’ve never kept recipes a secret. I’m honored if anyone likes it so much and why not let everyone enjoy it lol. I use to bake but gave that up years ago. I much prefer cooking meals. I’m also one of those cooks that uses a little of this and a little of that so I can only give the basic idea. I like to change recipes to what’s available or what I’m in the mood for.

    - Reply
    • Emily McKay Said:

      You know, Catslady, all this talk of food makes me wish we could have a Jaunty Quill pot luck! Lots of pine nuts all around!

      - Reply
  12. RobynDeHart Said:

    You know I’ve shared my sugar cookie recipe with several people and they all tell me that mine are better. I don’t get that. I’m not being coy cause I didn’t tweak it, it’s just a recipe.

    In any case, how you feel about your sister’s cheesecake, that’s how I feel about your key lime pie. I never order it anywhere b/c what’s the point, I’ve had the best.

    - Reply
    • Emily McKay Said:

      Thank you, friend!
      Oh, and your cookies are totally the best. Maybe it has to do with experience and confidence …

      - Reply
  13. Sheryl N Said:

    There is one that I love to make. It is a breakfast dish called Stuffed French Bread. I end up giving it out to anyone that asks. I don’t understand why someone wouldn’t share one.

    - Reply
    • Emily McKay Said:

      Sheryl, stuffed french bread sounds wonderful! Will you share it here?

      - Reply
  14. Danielle Gorman Said:

    I’m pretty open with all of my recipes. I love being able to share with others.

    - Reply
    • Emily McKay Said:

      Danielle, I love to share recipes too!

      - Reply
  15. bn100 Said:

    Don’t really cook, so no recipes to share

    - Reply
    • Emily McKay Said:

      bn100 … ha! Maybe that makes it easier.

      - Reply
  16. Heather E Said:

    Every Christmas I make peppermint bark at home for all of my husband’s coworkers. I even have one friend he no longer works with that remains on my list because she can’t get enough of it. I don’t tend to share my recipe because it is so simple, so easy that I’m almost embarrassed to share.

    I also have several party dips in my cookbook that are frequently requested. Many people tell me they use a ‘package’ or powdered base to get it started but it doesn’t turn out like mine. I am (fortunately it works to my benefit) allergic to many preservatives. So many dips, soups or starters contain MSG or other things that make me deathly ill. I’m always happy to share my recipes and often make cards with ingredients and directions to accompany my potluck dishes.

    - Reply
    • Emily McKay Said:

      Hmm .. those dip recipes sound good! Any chance you’ll share them?
      I’m one of those make-dip-from-a-packet people and I always wish I had a good recipe.

      - Reply
  17. Kirsten Said:

    My gran’s apple pie recipe was a secret for years and years. Then, on my 20 birthday, she gave me the recipe. So I could make it myself. Gran had never written it down, made it from memory. She died a short month later and I don’t think I would have gotten it otherwise, so I was really happy she gave it to me in time. I too keep it a secret, when asked I refuse to share. I think it’s what gran would have wanted.

    - Reply
    • Emily McKay Said:

      Kirsten, your post nearly made me cry. I’m sorry you lost your grandmother when you were only, but so glad she shared many years of good food first, and her apple pie recipe. I think recipes like that are a doorway to the past, to the people who’ve loved us, sometimes to the people we never even knew. I have my great grandmother’s sugar cookie recipe. Even though she died long before I was born, I think of her every time I make them.

      - Reply
  18. Kathryn in Montreal Said:

    Buttertarts… I have my grandmother’s recipe (and her pastry recipe) and they are amazing… have shared the recipe for the buttertarts once or twice but am told they just don’t taste the same as mine. Sometimes I think that what people remember is better than what it actually was. Also it’s a visual/feel sort of thing… there is a certain look to the buttertart filling and how it feels when stirred. And the pastry is easy and awesome – I totally don’t get why people find pastry intimidating and when it’s so easy and good why would you use store-bought.

    - Reply
  19. Laurie G Said:

    My great aunt Tressie would not share her chocolate angel food cake recipe with choc. whipped cream frosting. Finally my mom was able to convince her to share it with her. It became our traditional birthday cake and still is for my family.

    My MIL made the best cheese strudel. So thin and yummy it melted in your mouth. I’ve tried different recipes but none turn out the same. She used a little of this and a little of that…everything was by feel.

    - Reply
  20. Ann s. Said:

    My Aunt Ruth’s toffee carmel chocolate bars, she always sent them at Christmas. They are my Dads favorites and when I got married she started sending them to my family and not to him, her baby brother. He would always call to find out if Ruth’s package had arrived. When she got to old to bake anymore she sent the recipe to my son, she had shown him how to make them when he visited. He now makes them ALL of us at Christmas.

    - Reply
  21. Sharlene Wegner Said:

    I love cheesecake! I don’t make it, though. I do tweak the Nestle Tollhouse recipe. It isn’t a secret, though. I add a 3rd of a bag of butterscotch chips & 3rd of a bag of mini chips along with the full bag of chips. Just a little sweeter!

    - Reply

Leave a Comment

Comment a lot? Register here. Already registered? Login here.
Want your own gravatar? Get one here.

New Releases

Expecting Fortune's Heir-HR cover

A Little Bit Sinful--800

The Doctor and Mr. Right cover

Stroke of Genius (final) @ 800 high res

ifyougivearake-300

BESTMANfrontcover

highlandersmercy

Sizzle Blaze Feb

9780373732265_p0_v1_s260x420

His Valentine Bride-cover


Older Releases


Recent Posts


Links


Archives

By Category:

By Month:





Meta

Subscribe:

Register: