A while back, I wrote about certain trends I saw in romance novels—the heroine’s hair grows curlier the more she falls in love, for example, or the hero’s ability to dance a tango on a moment’s notice. Fun to read about or watch? Absolutely. True to life? Ah…no. Yet I love them anyway…well, mostly. Classics, we can call them. Or clichés. And I’ve used them too, so don’t think I’m getting all preachy here. Just observing, folks, just observing.
Everyone around me is selfish, mean, and well, pure evil, but I barely notice because I’m a saint. Granted, family members and coworkers, frenemies and old chums can push and prod all the most sensitive buttons, but come on. Show a little spine! Or even better, show some nice qualities in those evil siblings. The “I’ve always cared for her ever since our mother died” excuse just ain’t enough.
Thank goodness I have a wiser-than-his/her-years child advising me on my romantic disasters! I’ve never had a kid advise me on my love life. The kids in my life are good at telling me which Pokémon characters have the most power, sure. How to build a Lego structure in under five minutes using 2293 pieces, check. Why the hot guy I’ve always loved continues to ignore me? No! They have NOTHING! Clearly I must trade in these children for savvier, more observant children. Sorry, kids. I love you, but you’re not holding up your end. Yes, of course I’ll still buy you good presents. Don’t panic.
I’m a totally hot, red-blooded successful, good-hearted guy, but I’ve been celibate for several years now. Men think about sex every six seconds, right? So if you’re all of the above, what are you? A castrati? Seriously…no nooky? None? For how long? Honest? Really? Where have you been living? Prison? A desert island? Because otherwise, mister, I think you may need a trip to the doctor. By the way, you’re welcome for the picture of Mr. Butler there. I know!
Though I am shockingly beautiful, amazingly wealthy and extraordinarily talented, was educated by nuns in the Swiss Alps, speak seven languages and currently have my own Secret Service detail, I’m really just a regular joe. That’s right. She may be an heiress, but she loves swilling Budweiser with the coal miners and goes on to kick their butts at the pool table. This woman can cut loose, folks! She is so down-to-earth! Really, lady? Did finishing school have classes in pool/craps/poker? Did it? Really? Huh?
If I make you an omelette, it’s a sign that I’m one of the good guys. Just once, I’d like to see a guy whip up some Kraft dinner or call out for a pizza. Or burn the omelette! Granted, cooking for someone can definitely be a sign of love. But why omelettes? Why not a ham sandwich or chicken divan? Oops…Uh, Higgins? In your fourth novel, the hero makes heroine an omelette. And he doesn’t burn it. Right. Well, told you it was a cliché.
You can tell I’m oozing with testosterone because I drive a wicked awesome car. And not just drive, baby. This car and I are one. It’s a Porsche—he keeps it in the barn under a tarp, and no mice live in the engine. Listen, missy. He rebuilt the beauty from an old soda can and a fender. It’s taken him years, but it’s perfect now. Which shows how committed he can be to you. (Or something.) Or, he’s filthy rich and drives the cars that make James Bond drool with envy. And he handles that thing, know what I’m saying? Which shows how good he is in bed. (Or something.) By the way, the picture? You’re welcome for that, too.
Okay, fess up! Are there romantic clichés that you could skip for a while? Tired of the cute dog (please, God, not that!), the nosy older relative, the perfect sister? Don’t want to see any more bets made in bars? Sick of…well, you tell me! What’s the difference between a classic and a cliché, or is there really any difference? I’ll pick a commenter and send her an ADVANCE COPY of All I Ever Wanted, available everywhere on August 1.



























































































Jul 6th
2010
1:52 pm
thea Said:
how about the tall, dark, handsome loner who has no friends, no social skills, and gives the heroine a full court press to bed. And we all know, in real life, that these people are usually criminals as in criminal minds, stalkers, serial rapists and killers. And the heroine thinks he’s just misunderstood. eeeeecks!
-
Jul 6th
2010
1:55 pm
Kristan Higgins Said:
Kathleen, I like the way your mind works! “Gerard, you may be a dolt, but if you take off your shirt and wash my car, all will be forgiven.” Thea, you’re hilarious! But it’s true! I read a book recently where the hero grabbed the heroine so hard she was bruised. And she liked it. Ew.
-
Jul 6th
2010
2:54 pm
Lori Said:
My favorite is the heroine who has never been in an altercation in her life that is a sharp shooter by the end of the story, that spans 1 week. She can shoot a bad guy, with percision, while on the back of a motor cycle and never have a hair out of place…this is the stuff good girl falling in love with dangerous guy is made of!
-
Jul 6th
2010
3:08 pm
Charity Said:
I pretty much tend to just roll with the flow on most things, but I’m really getting tired of the sister that almost every heroine seems to have that is perfect. That mom and dad love. That has the wonderful husband, 2.5 kids, perfect job as a neurosurgeon that she can perform while on the can. I’m sick of said sister doing nothing but put the heroine down because someone needs to help her see how truly gargoyle like she is.
-
Jul 6th
2010
3:15 pm
Ashlee Said:
A friend and I were just having a discussion about clichés in stories the other day. Some of the ones already posted are hilarious. Let’s see, I’m always annoyed with the grand misunderstanding because of lack of communication, especially if said misunderstanding is not resolved until ten years later (and ESPECIALLY if there’s a child involved with said misunderstanding); the clichéd abused hero/heroine (okay, abuse exists, but in most novels I feel like it’s just a gimmick used to manipulate the reader’s emotions); the twenty-nine year old, gorgeous, sexy virgin (I’m not doubting that they exist, but come on); the bitter, burned by a past relationship, all men are scum heroine.
-
Jul 6th
2010
3:47 pm
DENEEN Said:
Definitely the heroine having a child by the hero and his not knowing it, especially in modern romances. It’s just something I find to be insensitive to the needs of the child and the father unless the father is abusive(and thus wouldn’t be the hero.) I’d prefer to see a custody battle ensue with the couple finally reconciling and getting back together rather than the worn out lies to hide paternity.
-
Jul 6th
2010
4:25 pm
Ann M. Said:
I had to laugh at some of the cliches you mentioned – especially the wonderful male who is stays celibate for years on end.
I stayed away from historical romances for years because I started to feel the women were all femmes fatales. I discovered many of historicals that are out now these women are wonderfully savvy.
Gone are a lot of the stereotypes that I remember.
-
Jul 6th
2010
4:31 pm
RobynDeHart Said:
What I want to know is what’s up with all the YA heroines who are so clumsy it’s a wonder they don’t just randomly walk into walls. I mean I get that you want her to be an everyman kind of character, but we don’t want her to injure herself just walking to class. It’s an odd thing I’ve seen now in several YA novels.
Great post, Kristan, and great comments from everyone.
-
Jul 6th
2010
4:45 pm
Rebecca (Becky) Alizadeh Said:
The things I’m tired of seeing in romance novels are…
Filthy stinkin’ rich cowboys from Texas. I live in Texas. Have my whole life. Never met a single, educated, richer-than-God, sexy, works the “family spread” that’s the size of Rhode Island cowboy/man in my entire life!
Thank goodness it’s no longer the 80s where ALL romance novels consisted of an A-hole of an Alpha Male A-hole (I meant to say that twice) “hero” and a desperate “willing to tolerate anything because of lack of choices/money/position in the world” heroine. He was always flawed for some reason that only “True Love” could fix and she knows that, for whatever reason, he only needs love. Her love. Make me want to vomit. They always had stupid titles, too. Things like, “The Executive’s Woman” or “He Gave Her No Choice”… LOL
-
Jul 6th
2010
4:50 pm
Rebecca (Becky) Alizadeh Said:
The other thing I’m noticing more and more with romance writers… and they know exactly who they are, too… they’re taking the crap they wrote back in the late 80s, early 90s; slapping a new cover on it; and reselling them like brand new books.
That really makes me angry. Plus, some writers seem to have their word processors set and all they do is change the names and locations of the stories. That’s it. That’s annoying, too. It means they’re only interested in the bottom line in their book business as opposed to writing things that are creative and will take their reader on a journey. Stepping off my soap box…
-
Jul 6th
2010
5:07 pm
Maya M. Said:
haha on the omelett! Colin Firth rescued Bridget Jones disaster dinner with an omelett and Roger Moore James Bond saved the day once with omelett instead of guns or scuba gear.
I have a micro-cliche to offer: when the heroine is trekking through the jungle with no supplies/ emerges from a collapsed building/ has been on a desert island for days following shipwreck – and still has perfect lipstick (this happens mostly on TV but I can well imagine it in books).
-
Jul 6th
2010
5:18 pm
Mary M Said:
Why are the servants in a wealthy family always able to bestow extraordinary wisdom and advice under any circumstances? Don’t servants have to work so hard they don’t have time for insightful reflection on others’ problems?
-
Jul 6th
2010
6:57 pm
Kristan Higgins Said:
Ah, yes, Maya and Mary…very good! Becky, I am shocked–SHOCKED, I tell you–that you have yet to meet a billionaire rancher. I feel so betrayed. Did I watch Dallas for nothing all those years?
-
Jul 6th
2010
7:11 pm
Diana Said:
I don’t really buy the whole hot guy being celibate for years. Maybe some writers do that because they don’t want the readers to view the hero as a mhore (man whore), but I don’t find it believable that a healthy, well-adjusted, good-looking guy (the list goes on) would choose to remain celibate for years. Weeks or months maybe, but not years. Oh, and the virgin heroine who just knows how to get it on in bed and is willing to try anything (she just needed the right guy to bring out her wild side) gets old sometimes.
-
Jul 6th
2010
8:48 pm
Kristan Higgins Said:
Ah, the virgin tigress, Diana! Are they still out there, lurking in the jungles, just waiting for those hot, celibate guys?
-
Jul 7th
2010
8:14 am
Gwen Roman / aka Jen McAndrews Said:
oh, this is perfect! I’m just going to save this post and all its comments and paste it into my notebook as a warning for future projects.
Now to go tell my current hero he has to get rid of the Ferrari….
-
Jul 7th
2010
11:08 am
Elvira Said:
I love the ones where the “Heroine” and I use the word lightly keeps a child from the hero, but explains why in all the years she never told him about the child (usually because of hurt pride) and all is forgiven. It’s not a problem it is looked at as it happens now lets get married and have more kids. I recently read a book were the hero did not find out about the kid until well into the story and it was the whole purpose of her coming to town. Don’t get me wrong they are written really good and I DID like the story I would even recommend it. The problem is it just doesn’t seem realistic and that there is no problem with it.
-
Jul 7th
2010
10:10 pm
LilMissMolly Said:
These are great! I am rather tired of the purse sized dogs. Please spare me! Since I’m into historicals, I don’t really see the “bar scenes” that much. The one scene that I am rather tired of is virgins having the Big O. I’m sorry, but it’s just not believable and sooo many authors have written those scenes. Why not make it the 2nd or 3rd time they do it and I’ll believe it.
-