Cindi Myers guest blogs on the imperfect heroine

Part of the appeal of romance novels is the wonderful fantasy — the perfect heroine meets the perfect hero and, after exciting struggles and adventures, falls in love forever. I buy into all of that, and enjoy picturing myself as that beautiful, strong, brave, smart and talented woman winning the man with gorgeous eyes, perfect hair and sexy, muscular body.

But sometimes I want to read about someone who is more like me. A woman with a few flaws — not just emotional flaws, but physical ones. I can relate to a woman who has bad hair days, chipped nails and is a few pounds (or more than a few pounds) overweight. I want to believe that an imperfect woman can still win the man who is perfect for her — whether he looks like Adonis or not.

My new book, The Man Most Likely, features a heroine who is a size 16 and determined NOT to lose weight. She’s focused on learning to love herself just as she is. Angela Krisova owns a chocolate shop and appreciates the good things in life — including good food. She’s not into deprivation and dieting; she just wants to be happy. She’s making great progress, too, until one of the best-looking men in town, Bryan Perry, starts pursuing her. Falling for a guy who until now has dated only the hottest looking women in town, Angela suffers through self-doubts.

I really loved writing about Angela. To me, she’s one of my most real heroines, struggling with the image issues I and so many other women struggle with. And I loved pairing her with a hunk like Bryan because I believe love happens in the mind and heart, and the workings of true attraction aren’t always understandable. I had fun writing a guy who is bowled over by a woman who is definitely not his ‘type.’ Bryan struggles with his attraction to Angela, but even after he gives in and admits he loves her, he has to deal with the perceptions of other people, who have a hard time seeing him and Angela as a couple. Bryan and Angela’s love goes beyond surface appearances. I can believe a couple like that will find their happily-ever-after.

While I’ve written several less-than-perfect heroines, I have to admit I haven’t yet tackled a homely hero. I don’t know if readers are ready for that. Which is odd, really. My own husband was overweight when I met him (though he’s slimmer now) and I’ve known plenty of balding guys I thought were really sexy. I think women are much more willing to overlook a lack of physical beauty in a man — personality really does matter more to us.

Except when it comes to heros in books. I could be wrong about this. What do you think? Are you more willing to accept an imperfect heroine than a homely hero? What would you think of an overweight hero or one who was really short or bald?

What about heroines? Do you enjoy reading about more ordinary women, or do you want your heroines as beautiful as your heroes are handsome?

Cindi Myers is the author of more than three dozen novels, including The Man Most Likely, available this month from Harlequin American Romance. The Man Most Likely is the follow-up to her Rita-nominated title, The Right Mr. Wrong. For more about Cindi, visit her website at www.CindiMyers.com

9 Comments
Leave a Comment
Filed in: Jaunty Guests

Comments

  1. Frana Said:

    Hi Cindi! I had such laugh when I read about bald and overweight heroes :razz: I like not-so-perfect heroines because I can identify with them. Also, it’s a nice thought that even though you’re not perfect you can have a perfect man (a lest perfect to your eyes, other people eyes are a totally different thing). And that is a reason why the readers (in my opinion) can’t accept imperfect hero. We identify with heroine but her hero must be perfect for them to have a happy ending. And usually we see hero through heroines’ eyes and to her he is perfect (love is blind :lol: )

    - Reply
  2. kristan higgins Said:

    Congratulations on the new book, Cindi!

    I’m with you…I love ordinary, flawed heroines because I think everyone deserves a big love story, not just billionaires and beauties. As for a homely hero…I don’t mind! Homely doesn’t matter; sex appeal does. How else can one explain Mick Jagger?

    - Reply
  3. RobynDeHart Said:

    Thanks for joining us again, CIndi, and congrats on your RITA nomination!

    I think it boils down to that fantasy. What woman can’t relate to the dream of wanting the best looking guy in school asking her to prom? I think it speaks to our most inner desires when we were girls. There’s just something so appealing to think of the hot guy just falling head over heels for the least likely girl.

    My first book with Avon, Courting Claudia, had this scenario with a heroine who was overweight and didn’t change that to win her man. It’s a very appealing fantasy which is why to this day I’ve still received more fan mail for that book than any other.

    Great blog, Cindi, I’ll definitely be picking up a copy of your book!

    - Reply
  4. Kathryn Said:

    Kristan you are so right about Mick Jagger… but just think, the exact same physical characteristics can be applied to Keith Richards and I don’t find he has a smidgen of sex appeal!

    I think it is easier for us to identify with the flawed heroine because we recognize our own flaws and sympathize with hers. I notice more authors giving heros endearing physical flaws… a scar, slightly crooked teeth that make an appealing smile, too long hair, even bald but there just doesn’t seem to be a really flawed hero out there. Maybe it’s because we really hope there is a perfect guy for everyone.

    - Reply
  5. Shana Galen Said:

    I think I could like a flawed–bald, ugly, overweight–hero if the author made him likeable enough. It always seems strange to me when a less than perfect heroine is with this perfect-looking guy.

    - Reply
  6. Cindi Myers Said:

    Frana, I think you’re right about the fantasy of the perfect guy. Minor flaws are okay, but I think we want that fantasy.

    But the idea of writing a book about a homely guy with sex appeal — like Mick Jagger — is intriguing! I don’t think I’m up to the challenge, but it might be fun to read.

    What makes a guy sexy? For me, it’s being totally into the woman — she is everything to him and he lets her know it.

    - Reply
  7. Cindy Kirk Said:

    Cindi,

    I like reading about flawed heroes and heroines as long as they aren’t “too” flawed. Because I end up identifying with the heroine, I want her to be stronger, faster prettier and smarter than me.

    I hold the hero to even higher standards. One sign that he’s a jerk (without sufficient motiviation) and I close the book.

    Great topic!

    - Reply
  8. Cindi Myers Said:

    Yes, Cindy, I agree with you on the jerks — I have no patience for them.

    - Reply
  9. Emily McKay Said:

    Welcome, Cindy!
    I’ve been out of town on vacation, but I’m so glad I made it back in time to read about your wonderful new book!
    I love flawed heroines, especially plump ones. I think it makes them so identifiable. I mean, who hasn’t needed to lose a pound or two? Btw, anyone read Meg Cabot’s Heather Wells series? They’re mysteries about a now-plump former teen sensation. Really great books.
    As for imperfect heroes, I can think of several that people just love. The heroes from Lord of Scoundrels and the Ravin Prince come to mind.
    But I think the key to making it work is to have the imperfection be something that makes the hero tougher, more alpha, than he otherwise would have been.
    I do think it’s tricky though. You notice, I haven’t tried it yet either.

    - Reply

Leave a Comment

Comment a lot? Register here. Already registered? Login here.
Want your own gravatar? Get one here.

New Releases


Older Releases

Mammoth Book of Time Travel Romance Cover Dec 09

stormofpassion

Merry Christmas Cowboy-cvr

When Seducing a Duke

Taken by the Laird

A Cowboy Christmas

An Angel in Provence


Future Guests


Recent Posts


Links


Archives

By Category:

By Month:





Meta

Subscribe:

Register: