I have a theory that we all have an angst meter. Or rather we all fall somewhere along the angst meter. Allow me to explain. Now first of all when I say angst, I mean the agony and depression meaning rather than the nervousness meaning. But I feel like we all have a saturation level of how much anguish we’re willing to take when it comes to the entertainment mediums. Now I have come up with three handy categories to identify the levels of angst.
First and foremost we have books. People who read angsty novels can take the highest level of anguish, simply because reading tends to take several hours to a week or longer to complete a book. Books that would fall into this category would be
anything by Nicholas Sparks, Jodi Picoult and practically any book on Oprah’s book club. There are also some romance novels that can fall into this category, not so much in that the entire book is sad, but that there are parts that are so heavy, they tend to overwhelm. I read one years ago called The Marriage Bed by Stephanie Mittman, and I swear I started crying in chapter one and didn’t stop until long after I loved the book.
Next up we have the movie category. It’s second because at the most these films tend to only take up three hours of our lives.
Here we have flicks like The Hours, Atonement, The English Patient and PS I Love You. There are hundreds more in this category and again the movie might not end on a bad note, but the intense emotion throughout the movie is what matters.
Finally our third category is songs. Angst-ridden music that just tugs at your heart, there are artists who have made entire careers on these tunes. Sarah McLachlan, for one. Lots of love ballads are tear jerkers. And country and western music is full of wrenching songs like John Michael Montgomery’s The Little Girl or Reba McEntire & Kenny Chesney’s new duet Every Other Weekend. I’ll admit, this is where I fall and country music is at the top of my list. I love it because it almost always tells a story and the angst in that 3.5 minutes is just about all I can handle. My mom, on the other hand, loves sad books and movies, but can’t stand sad music. Go figure.
There are so many popular angsty movies that I’ve never seen simply because I know that I won’t be able to handle them. It’s never really about whether or not I’ll like them, but I’m one of those people that gets totally lost in characters, and the emotion tends to overwhelm me. I actually cried so hard in one movie that I got sick afterwards and vomited in the parking lot afterwards. Is that too much sharing?
So there are certain flicks I steer clear of. Last Christmas though my mother MADE me go see PS I Love You with the rest of the women in my family, now I knew ahead of time that this would not be a movie for me. I told her so. And I was right. I hated it. I cried and cried and cried and there was no funny to relieve me. I know that husbands die, but I don’t want to think about that, even for two hours. Same goes for books, I don’t intentionally read books that I know are going to run me through the emotional ringer. Just not my thing. Call me a coward, I can take it.
Here’s one of my favorite angsty songs, though there are tons more.
So how about you? Where do you fall on my angst meter?



























































































Dec 2nd
2008
9:29 am
Emily McKay Said:
I’m an angsty movie girl, myself. But only very rarely. I did love The Notebook … but hated, hated, hated Message in Bottle (I sat in the movie theatre through the end of the credits, just in case he turned up alive. Hated that movie.) I love Out of Africa, but only watch it about once a decade. I was a teenager when Always came out. I cried so much that someone asked if I needed them to get the manager.
So you’d think I was actually too much of a wimp for movies (given those stories) and that would put me in the song category. Except songs are so short, I end up just feeling manipulated and that annoys me. It’s like watching a Michael Bay movie, the emotion is just shoved down your throat.
Obviously, I spent too much time thinking about this kind of thing.
Btw, Robyn, what movie made you puke?
-
Dec 2nd
2008
9:50 am
Shana Galen Said:
I can’t take angsty books. I read maybe 2 or 3 a year, usually about animals. I will occasionally see an angsty movie, but they’re not my first choice. I actually don’t even like angsty songs. Steven Curtis Chapman has a song titled “Cinderella,” and I cannot listen to even the first verse. Maybe I’m just too emotional? I think I’m way down on the angst meter.
-
Dec 2nd
2008
9:53 am
RobynDeHart Said:
Emily, that movie was When a Man Loves a Woman – the one where Meg Ryan plays an alcoholic. It was the little girls that did me in, it was terrible (my crying, not the movie). I don’t think I’ve seen it since.
-
Dec 2nd
2008
11:04 am
Margo Maguire Said:
Marley and Me choked me up a few times, but I usually avoid that kind of reading. And movies. And songs. When I was young, I wasn’t all that emotional. I didn’t really relate to sad stuff – or maybe I had a nice compartment to put it in, since I was an ICU nurse then. But now, sad stuff really hits me.
-
Dec 2nd
2008
12:33 pm
Nancy Robards Thompson Said:
I must be weird, because there are certain times when I love a good angsty book/movie/song just so I can have a good cry. I can get out all that emotion, mop up my tears, and get on with it. I guess I love getting caught up in emotion… Well, that is when I can blow into my hankie in private – not necessarily in public. That happened to me once, quite unexpectedly. My husband and I went to see a play (not a well known one. In fact, I can’t even remember what it was called) and there was a story line about a woman coping with the death of her little girl and I bawled – no, convulsed – uncontrollably. I was so embarrassed because I couldn’t stop. It was one of those small theatres in the half-round and we were on the front row – ugggg, so embarrassing. So, I guess I don’t like angst to take me by surprise — and it just dawned on me that I have a hard time with some country music because it makes me cry (Robyn, I’m still sniffling from your video clip
). I must be really weird because I can deal with the books and movies (in private or the dark back row of the theatre), but I have a harder time with songs that sneak up on me and wring out the tears in public. So, I must be a closet angster.
-
Dec 2nd
2008
3:36 pm
Mary M Said:
I cry when Frosty the Snowman melts. My angst meter fluctuates though — what makes me cry one day won’t make me cry on another.
-
Dec 2nd
2008
4:05 pm
Shirley Karr Said:
My angst meter must be at about zero. Even some Hallmark commercials make me cry. If I can help it, I don’t read, watch, or listen to sad stories. Wouldn’t even watch Shawshank Redemption until a friend said I’d be happy with the ending. There’s a romance author I used to love reading because her stories were fun and funny, but with each book her black moments got darker and darker until I couldn’t read her anymore.
-
Dec 2nd
2008
4:48 pm
Jane Said:
“Beaches” and “Steel Magnolias” always makes me cry.
-
Dec 2nd
2008
7:03 pm
catslady Said:
It’s right up my alley. I guess the angsty literature/movies/songs stay with me the longest. I mean would Gone with the Wind been any good if it was a HEA or Romeo and Juliet! And when they change the ending of a movie to HEA that wasn’t the way the original book ended, I get crazy.
-
Dec 2nd
2008
9:03 pm
victoria Said:
I have an amusing anecdote about watching an angsty movie. My mom, sister and I went to see the The Notebook……………….spoilers ahead……………………………………There we were: watching, enjoying, and crying our eyes out–so much that my eyes were sore and my nose was runny. Finally they were dying and not a sound could be heard in the theater. Well I could not take the crying any more–so I started laughing. I could not control my laughter–I was gnawing on my shirt to stifle my giggles. Both my sister and my mother slammed their elbows into my ribs and then….they started laughing. Finally….they die and the credits roll…giggles spewed forth. Several other people started laughing as well. We sat there 15 minutes laughing non stop. Then we laughed another 15 minutes in the car. We still laugh when we remember it. For Valentine’s Day, my sister gave my mom and I the DVD of the movie.
-