So I’ve just written the scene in my latest book in which my characters …. um, ahem … well, for the sake of keeping this post PG, let’s just say they were “playing canasta.” Now I for one have never been a fan of having characters “play canasta” in exotic or strange locals. I’ve always thought beds were nice and comfortable. Kitchen tables, not bad. In the office break room, yeah, it could work. Anything more than that starts to strain my willing suspension of disbelief.
If characters are “playing canasta” up against a tree in the Amazonian rainforest, for example, I start thinking things like, “Wow, isn’t that bark sharp?” or “Wouldn’t you be too busy watching for pumas to really enjoy what you’re doing?”
As a teenager, I remember reading a western in which the hero and heroine “played canasta” while on horse back. I’ve never been much of a rider myself, but this seemed believable to me. After all, horses are smart. They’re not going to jump off a cliff if the riders are distracted. I’m saying I’d want to do that myself, but believed it was physically possible. A few years later, I read a similar scene in a contemporary. But this time, it was on the back of a motorcycle. Seriously. And no, the guy didn’t have super powers or anything like that.
Needless to say, I put down that book. Which brings me to my point. In the scene I just wrote, my characters “play canasta” on the beach. And I’m a little worried the reader is going spend the whole scene thinking, “Yeah, but what about all that sand?”

So what do you think? Is that kind of thing distracting or romantic?
Filed in: Jaunty Post



















































Nov 17th
2008
11:56 pm
Mary M Said:
I don’t think it’s distracting because sex on the beach is so classic. But if it’s set in Dubai, I’ll be thinking about whether they’ll be arrested.
-
Nov 18th
2008
8:26 am
Margo Maguire Said:
It’s all in the execution, Emily! I bet you can make your readers get into it – even if it’s on horseback!
-
Nov 18th
2008
9:10 am
Shana Galen Said:
Oh, I think the beach is reasonable. That wouldn’t distract me at all. yes, there’s the sand issue, but hopefully they’d have a towel.
-
Nov 18th
2008
10:23 am
RobynDeHart Said:
I agree, totally about execution and I have no doubt you pulled it off. Think of how many historical characters get busy in carriages, that couldn’t have possibly been comfortable considering the tight quarters or narrow seats, but my readers never complain.
I think it’s romantic.
-
Nov 18th
2008
4:16 pm
Kathryn Said:
I always think about situation/setting/timing for playing canasta (love it!!!). For me, a biggie is first thing in the morning, waking her up with a deep kiss… what about morning breath??? In the shower first thing in the morning… YES! I tend to put myself in the situation and if it’s believable and romantic, of course it will work… but we have to look at how it works (or doesn’t) in real life.
-
Nov 18th
2008
4:18 pm
Shirley Karr Said:
Yup, it’s all in the execution and sometimes a little explanation, either overt or less obvious. Like in a historical, especially westerns, when they’ve been riding cross country for days, dirty and sweaty — as soon as they wade across a river or come across a natural hot springs, you know they’re gonna play canasta pretty soon because the idea of playing canasta covered with days of sweat and dirt just makes most modern readers go eww.
-
Nov 18th
2008
5:09 pm
Emily McKay Said:
Yeah, playing canasta early in the morning is never appealing to me in books, just ’cause personally, I’d much rather be sleeping. I’m so not a morning person.
But carriages in historicals? Yeah, that totally works. I think an entire generation of women have loved the idea ever since that scene in the Age of Innocence with the glove.
But, Shirley, you’re dead on about the natural hot springs. Back when Elizabeth Lowell wrote historicals I thought the American west must have been littered with natural hot springs.
-
Nov 19th
2008
11:52 am
Kristan Higgins Said:
I’m gonna have to go with distracting here…once read a canasta scene that took place on a bale of hay. All I could think was “rash.”
-
Nov 19th
2008
12:17 pm
Emily McKay Said:
Ick. Hay? Last time I sat on hay for a hay ride, I got flea bits. And let’s face it. there are places you don’t want flea bits.
-