I’m an AmericanIdolHolic and I’m in the mood to talk AI.
I’ve watched American Idol since the beginning. I have never missed a season. In fact, once it’s over for the year, I go through withdrawal. Tuesday nights just don’t seem the same without AI on Fox.
Season One–I was happy Kelly Clarkson won. Justin G just didn’t do it for me. Of all the other seasons, Carrie Underwood is my favorite contestant. I also have to admit I was a Clay Aiken fan and really,really,really wanted him to win.
This season? My favorites are David A and David C.
What about you?



























































































Apr 5th
2008
7:34 am
brownone Said:
Oh I LOVE Idol! I like Carly (the Irish girl) and the Michael Johns. I do like David A. but I think he’s kinda boring. I know, I must be the only one on earth that thinks like that but sometimes I think the songs he chooses are too old for him. (I wish he’d do like David C. and change it up a little)
-
Apr 5th
2008
8:26 am
AndreaW Said:
I’m a huge AI fan, too!! I’ve been watching it from the start as well. My faves this year are Michael Johns, David Cook, Carly Smithson and Brooke White. Sorry, but David A realllllly gets on my nerves. I mean, he sings good and all, but I’m over that “Golly gee, you really think I’m good?” act.
-
Apr 5th
2008
9:24 am
Virginia H. Said:
I am with Andrea on David A. I think he is a brown nose and his goofy smile gets on my nerves, he can sing but he’s a little on the boring side. I like Michael J, David Cook for the guys and Brook for the ladies. I think a guy will win this year. It will be between Michael and David Cook.
-
Apr 5th
2008
12:00 pm
Cindy Kirk Said:
You’re right about David A….but I think some of the boring part is because he’s young. Did you know he was on Starsearch (remember that show?) when he was thirteen or so….and won $100,000??
I totally forgot about Michael Johns…who I like too! His accent is the best.
Of the girls, Brooke is my favorite but I really think the finals will be between two guys.
-
Apr 5th
2008
1:55 pm
Shirley Karr Said:
Nope, not us. Even having a contestant from just down the road from us (Kristie Lee) isn’t enough to get my dh over his aversion to reality TV and especially singing.
We had Dancing w/the Stars on the other night in the background while we were reading (wanted to see if Marlee Matlin was still in the running), and it took the entire hour-long episode to announce who was out. Ugh. Can’t stand slow pacing. Give me Cash Cab on the Discovery Channel, where the questions and answers and results come fast and fun!
-
Apr 5th
2008
2:49 pm
Shana Said:
Hey, Cindy, I don’t watch it either. I just don’t have time to watch any TV show faithfully.
-
Apr 5th
2008
5:38 pm
Jane Said:
I’m a big David A. and Michael Johns fan. Originally, I didn’t like David Cook, but he’s definitely changed my mind these past several weeks. He’s been amazing.
-
Apr 5th
2008
9:21 pm
Cindy Kirk Said:
Jane,
I agree about David Cook. Originally he didn’t do much for me either, but he’s really impressed me these past few weeks.
-
Apr 5th
2008
11:05 pm
catslady Said:
I watched and really like K. Clarkson and Clay Aiken. This time I like Carly for the girls and then both David’s.
-
Apr 7th
2008
11:00 am
smile0303 Said:
Not a fan of AI because it always changes my favorite show, Bones, schedule.
-
Jun 10th
2010
10:12 pm
Allison Hill Said:
David cook has one of the great voices that i have ever heard in american idol’-~
-
Jun 11th
2010
7:20 am
Cindy Kirk Said:
Allison,
I agree with you…and I LOVE the songs he’s released. America made a good choice with him.
-
Jul 15th
2010
11:45 pm
Thomas Williams Said:
I could say that David Cook deserves to be a winner in American Idol. he posses great talent..”~
-
Aug 30th
2010
11:10 am
Trinity James Said:
David Cook is way better than that David Archuletta kid,`~
-
Oct 11th
2010
2:28 am
William Moore Said:
i would have to say that adam lambert have a much better voice than david cook*”-
-
Oct 22nd
2010
11:52 am
Polypropylene : Said:
David Cook’s vocal range is very good, i bet that he would be more famous in the future:.-
-
Dec 12th
2010
12:14 pm
Sodium Ascorbate Said:
both David Cook and David Archuleta are the best in my opinion, they have this unique voice “.’
-